=====
From elias@users.sourceforge.net:
This looks very good. To be a real master-piece though, I'd expect even more detail, and more technical polishing, e.g. the lighting on the figures to the right looks odd - they seem almost entirely black but the floor they stand on is lit.

=====
From fmurr@free.fr:
Bad points are the cracking of the ground too
straight and perhaps a less complicated texture for the devil's body in the rift
valley (for us to see him).Good points are composition,lighting.

=====
From zebu@pingou.linux-site.net:
just 2 remarks (they didn't influence my vote...) : Gandalf was wearing grey, not blue. And the bridge was outside of the Moria, no need for a roof since it's an outdoors scene...
=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
The columns and entryways have an interesting look to 
them.  The various figures look pretty good.  I like the 
use of contrasting lights here.

=====
From peter@table76.demon.co.uk:
A difficult scene to illustrate IMHO, but a good interpretation of it.


=====
From file:
good effect in the wizard´s robe.