=====
From elvish_archer@mailcity.com:
the concept is really cool , u only need to add the lightside and darkside more strong, beside the volume light 

=====
From darwallace@earthlink.net:
Light in undersea scenes, as with surface ones, comes from the sun unless you have submersible flashlights.  Filter it through the chaotic surface and add refraction.

=====
From pbourke@swin.edu.au:
Good look to the school of fish, the objects don't work.
Cans should be partly crumpled, the gun is "floating".
Rocks aren't bad either.

=====
From luisvaloyes@malditasea.zzn.com:
good fishes. but the objects just look as if they had been carefully placed on the sea floor right before taking the shot. I don't know the software, but I think you might have used some textures to make it all look dirty, or at least that it has been under the sea for a little time, with any kind of dust or something like that.

=====
From dvnss@mega.ist.utl.pt:
ingenious, but still not convincing!


=====
From marlo.steed@uleth.ca:
Nice concept.  Nice modeling and textures.... but the scene is too clean.  Dirty up the scene... the sand needs some bump map.

=====
From whitey@telefragged.com:
"Put up your hands, or I'll primitive you to death!" or "Don't move, he's got a torus!"

=====
From gregj56590@aol.com:
Highest photorealism of all the entries.
=====
From bbowen@cswnet.com:
I'm not sure how the droplet system works, but I really like the multi-directional, smooth flow of the school of fish.

=====
From Alain.Culos@bigfoot.com:
Well, your english is pretty good and your disclaimer is not necessary
;-)
I like the swarm effect of the fish, very nice.
There is movement in this picture and I like that.

=====
From husakm@vscht.cz:
Urealistic, the gun will be probably deeper in the sand ...

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
Some nice work here.  The gun in particular looks good.  
The plants look interesting, but seem more fantastical in 
nature than the other objects in the scene.  I like the 
texture on the rocks.

=====
From sjlen@ndirect.co.uk:
This all looks very clean and very CG.  I like the fish and the plants. 

=====
From delfeld@mailcity.com:
No offense intended, but what is it in this picture asks me - either visually or conceptually - to look at this picture?  The composition seems hasty.