===== From povuser@gmail.com: A good job. I like the cat idea and the half-eaten fish. You seen to be good. It was a bit simple, so I took off a couple points, but not too much. A job well done. P.S. Can you send me a widesceen version. I want to use it for my desktop image, thanks. ===== From s.day@uel.ac.uk: Nice image, everything looks a bit too clean to be in the bin and your power cable appears to be connected to a tin can.. But that is just being picky. It's a great image and the modelling is good. The cat looks fine without real fur. ===== From file: At first glance everything looks good, clean, and cohesive. One thing that would help though is texturing/modelling the fur on the cat. It looks too smooth. Great concept though, it reminds me of some exploits of my own. Notable for lighting ===== From file: Good image and concept. Cat's fur could be a bit softer. Notable for modelling, originality, lighting ===== From file: Notable for textures, composition, modelling, originality, lighting