INTERNET RAY TRACING COMPETITION Voting form for November-December 2005 This Round's Topic: Speed -------------------------- REGISTRATION ------------ If you have already registered with the IRTC, enter your registration email address and password on the lines below. Make sure to keep the ">>>>> Registration ..." marker on the same line as your information. >>>>> Registration E-Mail Address: >>>>> Registration Password: Votes will be accepted from entrants and panel judges during the period 1 Jan 2006 through 14 january 2006. Comments are accepted at any time. If you have not yet registered, you may do so either of two ways: 1. Go to "http://www.irtc.org/register.html", the registration WWW page, and follow the instructions. 2. Send an email message to "irtc-vreg@irtc.org" containing a single line in the following format: your_email_address your_password Your email address should be of the form "username@address". Your password is any string you choose. Neither the address nor the password may contain spaces. Separate the address from the password by at least one space. Note that votes will only be accepted from those who entered an image in this round, or from members of the judging panel. See our ftp or web site for information about joining the panel. RATING THE IMAGES ----------------- Please download ALL the images listed below, and view each one before rating it. For each image, give it a rating between 1 and 20 (inclusive) in each of the three listed categories. 1 is the lowest rating, and 20 is the highest. Place each number at the end of its line which starts "Rate image.jpg for ..." IMAGES ------ The images, description files, and source files may be retrieved via ftp from "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/2005-12-31". We encourage you to add comments to the images below, giving your opinions on the images, what you liked, what you didn't like, and so forth. Place your comments between the lines with the ">>>>> Comments on ..." and ">>>>> End Comments on ..." markers. You may enter as many lines as you like. NOTE: your comments will be signed with your voter email address. image: abductio.jpg by Mike DeVose (48008 bytes) Description: abductio.txt Source File: (none given) Rate abductio.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate abductio.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate abductio.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on abductio.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on abductio.jpg image: allegro.jpg by Kevin Lynn (198005 bytes) Description: allegro.txt Source File: (none given) Rate allegro.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate allegro.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate allegro.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on allegro.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on allegro.jpg image: alspeed.jpg by Alain Longpr (219898 bytes) Description: alspeed.txt Source File: alspeed.zip Rate alspeed.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate alspeed.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate alspeed.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on alspeed.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on alspeed.jpg image: bowling.jpg by gozine (148582 bytes) Description: bowling.txt Source File: (none given) Rate bowling.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate bowling.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate bowling.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on bowling.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on bowling.jpg image: camarosp.jpg by Michael Munson (35348 bytes) Description: camarosp.txt Source File: (none given) Rate camarosp.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate camarosp.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate camarosp.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on camarosp.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on camarosp.jpg image: cameleon.jpg by Eric Ouvrard (236784 bytes) Description: cameleon.txt Source File: (none given) Rate cameleon.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate cameleon.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate cameleon.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on cameleon.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on cameleon.jpg image: caracols.jpg by CTRL+Z (Group of 3D Students) Jos_ Pedro Ramos; Susana Pacheco (132916 bytes) Description: caracols.txt Source File: (none given) Rate caracols.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate caracols.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate caracols.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on caracols.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on caracols.jpg image: cheetah.jpg by Steve Paget (227530 bytes) Description: cheetah.txt Source File: (none given) Rate cheetah.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate cheetah.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate cheetah.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on cheetah.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on cheetah.jpg image: computer.jpg by Nick Ryhajlo (21674 bytes) Description: computer.txt Source File: computer.zip Rate computer.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate computer.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate computer.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on computer.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on computer.jpg image: dcsnails.jpg by Denis Chassaing (254816 bytes) Description: dcsnails.txt Source File: (none given) Rate dcsnails.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dcsnails.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dcsnails.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dcsnails.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dcsnails.jpg image: escapeve.jpg by Glenn McCarter (242653 bytes) Description: escapeve.txt Source File: escapeve.zip Rate escapeve.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate escapeve.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate escapeve.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on escapeve.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on escapeve.jpg image: fast.jpg by Natalie Bisceglia (105698 bytes) Description: fast.txt Source File: (none given) Rate fast.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fast.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fast.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fast.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fast.jpg image: faster_t.jpg by Travis Schau (249137 bytes) Description: faster_t.txt Source File: (none given) Rate faster_t.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate faster_t.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate faster_t.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on faster_t.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on faster_t.jpg image: finalher.jpg by Reed Johnson (107922 bytes) Description: finalher.txt Source File: (none given) Rate finalher.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate finalher.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate finalher.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on finalher.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on finalher.jpg image: finalren.jpg by Sarvesh N (120106 bytes) Description: finalren.txt Source File: finalren.zip Rate finalren.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate finalren.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate finalren.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on finalren.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on finalren.jpg image: flatout.jpg by Brett Dickson (79563 bytes) Description: flatout.txt Source File: (none given) Rate flatout.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate flatout.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate flatout.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on flatout.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on flatout.jpg image: fullpull.jpg by John Gardiner (250046 bytes) Description: fullpull.txt Source File: fullpull.zip Rate fullpull.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fullpull.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fullpull.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fullpull.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fullpull.jpg image: grown_up.jpg by Tekno Frannansa (228615 bytes) Description: grown_up.txt Source File: grown_up.zip Rate grown_up.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate grown_up.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate grown_up.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on grown_up.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on grown_up.jpg image: irtc_spe.jpg by Charles H. Rousseau (122506 bytes) Description: irtc_spe.txt Source File: (none given) Rate irtc_spe.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate irtc_spe.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate irtc_spe.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on irtc_spe.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on irtc_spe.jpg image: jatocar.jpg by Edward Thomas (63851 bytes) Description: jatocar.txt Source File: (none given) Rate jatocar.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate jatocar.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate jatocar.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on jatocar.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on jatocar.jpg image: jcbullet.jpg by Joel R Cook (219436 bytes) Description: jcbullet.txt Source File: (none given) Rate jcbullet.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate jcbullet.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate jcbullet.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on jcbullet.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on jcbullet.jpg image: jude.jpg by Jude Courmier (96907 bytes) Description: jude.txt Source File: (none given) Rate jude.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate jude.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate jude.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on jude.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on jude.jpg image: karatekd.jpg by Iacopo Mochi (204999 bytes) Description: karatekd.txt Source File: karatekd.zip Rate karatekd.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate karatekd.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate karatekd.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on karatekd.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on karatekd.jpg image: licencep.jpg by Bryce Johnson (82537 bytes) Description: licencep.txt Source File: (none given) Rate licencep.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate licencep.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate licencep.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on licencep.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on licencep.jpg image: light.jpg by Leroy Whetstone (17111 bytes) Description: light.txt Source File: (none given) Rate light.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate light.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate light.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on light.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on light.jpg image: mach1.jpg by Laurence A. Feldman and Shane Moura (112036 bytes) Description: mach1.txt Source File: mach1.zip Rate mach1.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate mach1.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate mach1.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on mach1.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on mach1.jpg image: mbspeedy.jpg by Mark "scottishpig" Burger (73471 bytes) Description: mbspeedy.txt Source File: mbspeedy.zip Rate mbspeedy.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate mbspeedy.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate mbspeedy.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on mbspeedy.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on mbspeedy.jpg image: meteorsc.jpg by Ben Fisk (29163 bytes) Description: meteorsc.txt Source File: (none given) Rate meteorsc.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate meteorsc.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate meteorsc.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on meteorsc.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on meteorsc.jpg image: modem.jpg by Matt Fruge (39520 bytes) Description: modem.txt Source File: (none given) Rate modem.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate modem.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate modem.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on modem.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on modem.jpg image: nothing.jpg by Enrique Sahagun Alonso (230104 bytes) Description: nothing.txt Source File: (none given) Rate nothing.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate nothing.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate nothing.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on nothing.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on nothing.jpg image: physicsh.jpg by Nick Swider (225919 bytes) Description: physicsh.txt Source File: physicsh.zip Rate physicsh.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate physicsh.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate physicsh.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on physicsh.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on physicsh.jpg image: plane.jpg by Kristian Welsh (95114 bytes) Description: plane.txt Source File: (none given) Rate plane.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate plane.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate plane.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on plane.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on plane.jpg image: ratrod.jpg by Scott Schmidt (236897 bytes) Description: ratrod.txt Source File: ratrod.zip Rate ratrod.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate ratrod.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate ratrod.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on ratrod.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on ratrod.jpg image: rdgspeed.jpg by Robbert de Groot (86554 bytes) Description: rdgspeed.txt Source File: rdgspeed.zip Rate rdgspeed.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rdgspeed.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rdgspeed.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rdgspeed.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rdgspeed.jpg image: rjohnson.jpg by Reed Johnson (69627 bytes) Description: rjohnson.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rjohnson.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rjohnson.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rjohnson.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rjohnson.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rjohnson.jpg image: road.jpg by Jon Swallow (61704 bytes) Description: road.txt Source File: (none given) Rate road.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate road.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate road.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on road.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on road.jpg image: rotate.jpg by GRAPHIKTO (229390 bytes) Description: rotate.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rotate.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rotate.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rotate.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rotate.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rotate.jpg image: rrracing.jpg by Boris Zhevlakov (197156 bytes) Description: rrracing.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rrracing.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rrracing.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rrracing.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rrracing.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rrracing.jpg image: rtcspeed.jpg by Nicolas Argyrou (237415 bytes) Description: rtcspeed.txt Source File: rtcspeed.zip Rate rtcspeed.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rtcspeed.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rtcspeed.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rtcspeed.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rtcspeed.jpg image: santa_s_.jpg by Kevin bess (150352 bytes) Description: santa_s_.txt Source File: (none given) Rate santa_s_.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate santa_s_.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate santa_s_.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on santa_s_.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on santa_s_.jpg image: scottroc.jpg by Scott Langfitt (85569 bytes) Description: scottroc.txt Source File: (none given) Rate scottroc.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate scottroc.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate scottroc.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on scottroc.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on scottroc.jpg image: sir_fs.jpg by Florian Siegmund (178157 bytes) Description: sir_fs.txt Source File: sir_fs.zip Rate sir_fs.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate sir_fs.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate sir_fs.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on sir_fs.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on sir_fs.jpg image: slowdown.jpg by Alexandre Dorion (239485 bytes) Description: slowdown.txt Source File: slowdown.zip Rate slowdown.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate slowdown.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate slowdown.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on slowdown.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on slowdown.jpg image: solar.jpg by Stephen Cattell (182115 bytes) Description: solar.txt Source File: (none given) Rate solar.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate solar.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate solar.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on solar.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on solar.jpg image: spdolife.jpg by Michael Chelmecki (236886 bytes) Description: spdolife.txt Source File: (none given) Rate spdolife.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate spdolife.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate spdolife.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on spdolife.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on spdolife.jpg image: speed.jpg by j h (92302 bytes) Description: speed.txt Source File: (none given) Rate speed.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on speed.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on speed.jpg image: speed_up.jpg by GRAPHIKTO (195346 bytes) Description: speed_up.txt Source File: (none given) Rate speed_up.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed_up.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed_up.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on speed_up.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on speed_up.jpg image: speed_wh.jpg by Roef Mahlmann (106381 bytes) Description: speed_wh.txt Source File: speed_wh.zip Rate speed_wh.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed_wh.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate speed_wh.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on speed_wh.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on speed_wh.jpg image: speedboa.jpg by Sarah Lofreddo (105114 bytes) Description: speedboa.txt Source File: (none given) Rate speedboa.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate speedboa.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate speedboa.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on speedboa.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on speedboa.jpg image: speedsig.jpg by Hannah Marchitto (23624 bytes) Description: speedsig.txt Source File: (none given) Rate speedsig.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate speedsig.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate speedsig.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on speedsig.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on speedsig.jpg image: subway.jpg by Michael Hunter (232985 bytes) Description: subway.txt Source File: (none given) Rate subway.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate subway.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate subway.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on subway.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on subway.jpg image: t_sprint.jpg by Paolo Gibellini (165188 bytes) Description: t_sprint.txt Source File: t_sprint.zip Rate t_sprint.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate t_sprint.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate t_sprint.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on t_sprint.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on t_sprint.jpg image: torthare.jpg by Diego Magnani (253005 bytes) Description: torthare.txt Source File: (none given) Rate torthare.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate torthare.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate torthare.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on torthare.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on torthare.jpg image: what4.jpg by Enrique Sahagun Alonso (244084 bytes) Description: what4.txt Source File: (none given) Rate what4.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate what4.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate what4.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on what4.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on what4.jpg image: wp_trail.jpg by Bill Pragnell (249966 bytes) Description: wp_trail.txt Source File: wp_trail.zip Rate wp_trail.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate wp_trail.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate wp_trail.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on wp_trail.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on wp_trail.jpg image: xtrmcpu.jpg by Eero Ahonen (66390 bytes) Description: xtrmcpu.txt Source File: xtrmcpu.zip Rate xtrmcpu.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate xtrmcpu.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate xtrmcpu.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on xtrmcpu.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on xtrmcpu.jpg ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ------------------- If you would like to add comments which are not related to any specific image, place them below, between the lines with the ">>>>>" markers: >>>>> Additional Comments: >>>>> End Additional Comments: SUBMITTING YOUR VOTE -------------------- For your vote to be accepted, you must rate every image in all three categories, except for your own image(s), if you entered this round. Once you have rated the images, and added any comments you might have, either email this form to "irtc-vote@irtc.org", or upload it via anonymous ftp to "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/vote". Votes will be accepted during the period 1 Jan 2006 through 14 january 2006. You will be notified at your voter email address once your vote has been processed. (Leave these lines alone!) >>>>> Competition subdivision: stills >>>>> Competition Period: 2005-12-31 >>>>> End Form