===== From skipt1@aol.com: Artistically appealing both visually and conceptually. The lighting is very good and the focal blur is a nice touch. The actual concept itself seems to be a little bit of a stretch though. Very unique entry and a good image. ===== From povray@doublezero.uklinux.net: Seems only just on-topic to me, but then again this was a very mixed round. I really like this picture, but a bit more depth-of-field would have made me happier. Also, the letterboxing really detracted from it for me. If you don't want a standard-aspect image, don't make one. ===== From shevlin@uic.edu: The focal blur adds a nice touch. The image needs something more than an empty white void in the background, though. How is this supposed to relate to the topic? ===== From hildurka@simnet.is: I really love you interpretation of the topic. It has a strong sense of reality and you are right, the Internet is really a source which contains stuff in epic proportions. Using chairs is straightforeward as most of the free models are actually chairs. The composition is good but I have some doubts about youe use of focal blur. But it_s always tricky. I also think the lighs could be ajusted for more dramatic results. But overall I like this image. ===== From renebui@aol.com: Light is excellent. ===== From sshelby@shelbyvision.com: I have no idea what this is about. ===== From file: Notable for composition, originality, modelling ===== From file: Good! Notable for composition, textures, originality, modelling