===== From tek@evilsuperbrain.com: The overall look and feel of the image is very good and very wintery. The ice is really nice and looks wet as if it's in the process of melting. I have a couple of minor criticisms: The reflection in the water is tinted too much, at this angle the water would be almost a perfect mirror. Also the heightfield used for the cliffs is too low res, so the slope map picks out the bumps caused by the pixels. But neither of these things spoil this nice image :) ===== From the_dark_allies@hotmail.com: The image appears to be a bit washed out. The ice and mountains need to have at least a good layer of texturing, it was hard to figure out they were mountains or waterfalls. You did a nice attempt at trying to simulate water, but when do you ever see green water in winter? Usually green is for tropics. ===== From rjhansen@myrealbox.com: Nice water. ===== From pokorny@attglobal.net: Best ice and cold water in the competition. ===== From tom@tomandlu.co.uk: Nice image, but the ice needs work. ===== From edward_dixon2001@yahoo.com: Love the ice and the water is nice. Not sure about the cliffs. ===== From lrwii@joplin.com: Nice reflections. Maybe to much. ===== From file: The mountains take away from the otherwise excellent ice-chunk.