===== From tony@j4tb.com: Your overall scene looks great except the water seems too solid. I think if you toned down the reflectivity of the water it would help. ===== From javaearl@hotmail.com: I love your use of color (keeping it dark...very cool.) Very decent turbulence in the water. ===== From warp@iki.fi: The connection between the image and the topic is very vague. You didn't explain the image nor how it was done. Sorry, low score. Looks like a heavier antialiasing would make good to the water. ===== From chris_hormann@gmx.de: Nice picture esp. water and lighting, but you should have really written some words about it, also because it's not clear how you relate it to the topic. ===== From jouni@mikrobitti.fi: Where's the wilderness? ===== From StephenF@whoever.com: Some very good elements here. The ship looks nice and detailed, and looks good. I also like the red moon. The star flares seem a little much, though. The mist around the mountains seems kinda "puffy"... I think it would look better if it were smoothed out some (if the mist on the right looked more like the mist on the left, that is). ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: Hardly fits my definition of "wilderness", but a pleasant crisp image nonetheless. Nicely divided into three zones: top, middle, and bottom. ===== From albiaprime@aol.com: Artistic - A nice picture Technical - Some information on how the image was created would have been useful. Did you create all the images or were some imported from other sources. Concept - Hard to find a wilderness here.