===== From witoslaw@kki.net.pl: GREAT :-D ===== From jerry@hoboes.com: The rock? below the welder is awfully smooth--looks like plastic. I find the 'floating particles' intriguing: they look like mysterious lights floating just outside the view of the welder. ===== From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de: Very good one. Although the object is not too complicated, the whole setup and lighing is very credible. I think the texture on the underskeleton of the robot is textured to strongly and regularly. I would imagine this is only simple metal. ===== From pdolan@jps.net: Work on ground texture - underwater is smoother than that ===== From Varyk@aol.com: is video post glow within the scope of the rules against adding post-rend= er special effects? ===== From djohnston@iname.com: The image looks too empty. Some extra (and larger) rocks would help (IMHO). The smoke looks amazing. The only other thing is that the atmosphere isn't very convincing. It just doesn't have the feel of water. I guess its not mirky enough or something,. ===== From gmccarter@hotmail.com: The water looks quite realistic, the way it fades into the distance and has suspended particles floating in it. Good welding flame, but shouldn't the "smoke" be bubbles instead? Nice modelling on the robot.